Thursday, June 14, 2007

 

The End Of Independant Thinking


Here's yet another reason why Canada's schools suck.
King said he was threatened with police action by Principal Susan Wilson previously after making the case that marijuana was less harmful than alcohol.

"In my opinion, cannabis is safer than they say, it is not worse than alcohol or tobacco," said King, a 15-year-old Grade 10 student.

A curious student goes home and researches a subject in which he's interested. He then discusses his findings with friends at school.

This is how people learn. When you find something interesting, and you dig up all the information you can on the subject. When you find people with similar interests, you share opinions as a group and learn from each others experiences.

Except in Canada. If your facts aren't contained in an education-board prescribed text book that's fifty years old, your opinion not only carries no weight, it's deemed to be dangerous. Asking questions which are not answered in the prescribed reading is exactly how an individual gains greater knowledge of a subject. Any fool can remember that 1+1=2, but if the pupil doesn't ask "Why?", or "How?", then they really haven't learned a damn thing!

What kind of message does this send to kids in our schools? If you ask too many questions and start to think independantly (ie. not agreeing with the school board), you're sorry ass will get suspended, and you're life will be ruined.

Kieran King is no slacker. He's an honor student with all of his grades in the 80's and 90's. And damn lucky for him. Due to his suspension, he'll be forced to miss his final exams. Due to his excellent academic work he'll still be able to pass. And unfortunately his transcript will reflect his ability to think independently as a negative.

With a school system that penalizes students for "thinking outside the box", it's no surprise that:
Compared with other industrialized countries, Canada is sinking in a pool of mediocrity that threatens to pull down our standard of living, says a new report from the Conference Board of Canada. [...]

The report card's results "tell a story of governments, businesses and people punching below their weight," its authors say. Even though the country is rich in natural resources and its population well educated, "too often we trail the pack. The failure to innovate is a large part of the explanation for our mediocrity -- a mediocrity that is hampering what we can do and what we can be."

Labels: , , ,

Comments:
i would have thought this to be ridiculous if it was anywhere other than a 600 person town in Saskatchewan.

The slogan for the town is "Progress through perseverance."

I bet there are 39 churches within 30km.
 
There might even be a Little Mosque on the Prairie.
 
Watch this video of a school official explaining her actions:

Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvc5zLee--8

Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxavtfDPZvE

Part 3: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FTDVdT-YjoI
 
i don't have the bandwith for youtube. i'm in siberia. can someone sum up the video's.
 
When you use the word "accountability" the way it is currently being used in the education system, and you introduce large-scale standardized tests of academic skills, you tend to see greater pressure on teachers to teach to the test. Kind of puts a damper on creative problem-solving and original thought.
 
and that is why I am home schooling my kid for the first several years.
 
Hi,

I'm from Slovenia, spent three summers in Winnipeg studying political science and I just saw this topic on End of independent thinking.

I'm sorry to hear this. However, I have to confess that this is just the same in any other country (also Slovenia). Ok, I never heard that someone was endangered by police threats, but in smoe areas truth is not welcomed. We have same problem, when there is almost no education on sexuality or alcohol (which is still reasons for meny deaths on Slovenian roads.
Accepting arguments of students as it was presented in your case needs great courage and knowledge of teachers to deal with such topic - and it is easier to start disciplinary procedure.

Just hope that we will keep at least some more freedom of thinking than in US. Best wishes.
 
Harry, I agree that free thinking is always threatened, no matter what country, or what government.

While it may take courage and knowledge from teachers to deal with these arguments from students, the arguments should be countered by reason and logic, not by the whip.
 
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?


Banner



pkblogs.com

On My Nightstand...




My blog is worth $7,903.56.
How much is your blog worth?


Banner